5

After some discussion on chat, we're realized the site has several list questions with many answers, mostly from the early days of the site.

Let's post candidate questions as community wiki answers to this thread, like this:

Question

  • Problems
  • Suggested cleanup actions: Deletion, editing, combining answers, whichever.

That second line is what people will vote on - agreement or disagreement to your suggestion action on the question.

Please vote up or down, and use the comments to discuss. Are these truly list questions? Can they be edited so they're of more value to the site? If you like one of these and want it to stick around, let's hear why.

13 Answers 13

3

What do you do to make positive you remember your water bottle?

  • This is a chatty, forum-style question.
  • Candidate for closure.
  • Closed as recommended – freiheit Mar 5 '12 at 23:55
3

What's your most useful cycle accessory?

  • This is a chatty, forum-style question.
  • Any unique answers can go to the Terminology Index, then we delete this. It's not referenced in that many places, so that shouldn't be a problem.
2

What do you wish someone had told you before your first commute?

  • This has 31 answers that go across 2 pages, it's a bit of a mess. It's also kinda chatty.
  • Maybe edit into fewer answers?
  • This is now at 33 answers, and I'd say "kinda chatty" is an understatement. :) – amcnabb Aug 10 '12 at 21:11
2

https://bicycles.stackexchange.com/questions/1466/recommended-good-value-cycle-lights-for-commute/1479#1479

  • Big unmaintainable list
  • Candidate for closure
  • 1
    Closed the question – freiheit Mar 5 '12 at 23:54
2

What are the most useful or interesting cycling-related websites or blogs?

  • Chatty forum-style question AND a big unmaintainable list
  • Candidate for closure
  • And now it's closed. – freiheit Jun 5 '12 at 17:05
2

Bicycling Apps for Android

  • It is a big list. It's slightly more maintainable than "Recommended Good Value Cycle Lights for Commute" because new Android apps aren't released quite as frequently, but it still seems destined to become outdated.
  • Candidate for closure.
2

Most Crucial Gear/ Accessories for a (Road) Cycling Beginner?

  • Chatty question specifically asking for subjective responses
  • Candidate for closure
2

Book Recommendation: Training

  • A list of books, which will always become outdated as new books are published. It is also impossible to come to any agreement on what the "best" book is.

  • Candidate for closure.

  • Agreed. I voted to close last year, but that vote has since expired. – Neil Fein Aug 8 '12 at 22:59
1

Best chain lubricant for road bikes?

  • This is an obvious list question, since there's no single answer that summarizes it.

  • I suggest deleting this and asking a question more along the lines of "What are the advantages and disadvantages of different kinds of lube for road bikes?"

  • 1
    Deleted as recommended – freiheit Mar 5 '12 at 23:55
1

What tips do you have for making temporary “get me home” repairs?

  • Chatty open-ended question
  • Candidate for closure
1

What is a good iPhone app for bikers?

  • A big list, which is difficult to maintain as new apps are added and as new versions of apps are released.
  • Candidate for closure
0

What advanced cycling skills are useful for a commuter or city rider?

  • Chatty forum-style question
  • Candidate for closure
0

Is there an easy to use app for tracking my cycling performance? (iOS or Android)

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .